SAMPLE Ethics in America
● Descriptive relativism observes that there are differences among ethical practices and standards ofdifferentcultures,withoutevaluationorjudgmentoftheirjustification.Itisbased on empirical fact and observation alone. ● Prescriptive relativism goes further, claiming that peopleoughtnottoapplythestandardsof one culture to evaluate the behavior of another culture.
The two forms of Ethical Relativism
Personal or individual relativism
Social or cultural relativism
● Moral attitudes of each individual person ● No one person is more correct than another ● Individual conscience is the only appropriate standard for moral judgment ● An ethical subjectivist view, because moral values are dependent on a will, human or divine Personal relativism is often a personal choice, as it can vary from one person to the next. Even so, there are many people who value this viewpoint and base their decisions on it.
● Ethical values vary from one society to another ● Consults the moral beliefs of the society to which they belong ● Based on the dependency thesis ● What is moral is dependent upon human nature or specific social and cultural circumstances Socially or culturally, the rules can vary. That is why it is necessary to consult your own society's moral system to know what is considered moral.
B. Support for Ethical Relativism
Support for ethical relativism usually centers around three reasoned arguments :
1. The diversity of moral views among peopleandculturesiswelldocumentedthroughhistory, anthropology, science, and other related disciplines. Philosophers have disagreed about the basis of morality since ancient times, and no universal agreement has ever been reached. 2. Moraluncertainty inourselvesandoursocietyindicatesthatwedonottrustourownjudgment, and are constantlyquestioningourselvesabouttherightthingtodo.Dowetellthetruthordo weprotectalovedone?Evenaftermakingadecision,weoftenwonderifwehavemadetheright choice. 3. Situationaldifferences betweenpeoplevarytosuchadegreethatitisdifficulttobelievethat the same things that wouldberightforonepersonwouldberightforanotherinallinstances. Somepeopleliveindirecircumstanceswherebasicamenitiessuchasfood,water,shelter,and securityarepracticallynon-existent,whileothersliveincomfortablecircumstanceswherethose necessities are plentiful. Some people live in oppressive societies where basic freedoms are denied, while others enjoy broadfreedoms.Shouldthechoicesmadebythepersonstruggling for survival be judged by the same moral compass as the person who lives comfortably and securely?
23
© 2024 ACHIEVE ULTIMATE CREDIT-BY-EXAM GUIDE|ETHICS IN AMERICA
Made with FlippingBook Ebook Creator